Edge Images Used in the Comparison

Parameters were adapted to each of the images:

(Helpful hint: If your web browser allows you to run more than one copy of it at the same time, as Netscape does, then you can use that feature to compare edge images.)

Image Canny Nalwa Iverson Bergholm Rothwell
golf cart s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.550 S_2.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
pitcher s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_0.60_l_0.15_h_0.60 n_4_l_0.000_h_0.050 S_2.0_s_1.5_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
stapler s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.300 S_5.0_s_1.5_t_10.0 s_1.00_l_8.0_a_0.95
mailbox s_1.20_l_0.40_h_0.60 b_0.60_l_0.15_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.300 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_1.00_l_8.0_a_0.90
pillow s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.300 S_3.0_s_2.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
brush s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_0.60_l_0.15_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.550 S_2.0_s_1.5_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
shopping cart s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.550 S_2.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_1.00_l_18.0_a_0.80
tire s_1.20_l_0.20_h_0.60 b_1.20_l_0.05_h_0.15 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_3.0_s_2.0_t_5.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
grater s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.300 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
basket s_1.20_l_0.40_h_0.60 b_0.60_l_0.05_h_0.30 n_6_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_3.0_s_1.5_t_10.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
orange s_1.20_l_0.40_h_0.80 b_1.20_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_3.0_s_1.5_t_10.0 s_1.00_l_8.0_a_0.90
banana s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_1.20_l_0.05_h_0.30 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_4.0_s_1.5_t_5.0 s_1.50_l_3.0_a_0.90
egg s_1.20_l_0.40_h_0.80 b_1.20_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_4_l_0.000_h_0.050 S_4.0_s_1.5_t_5.0 s_1.50_l_3.0_a_0.90
elephant s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_2.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_1.00_l_13.0_a_0.80
pond s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_0.60_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.550 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
pinecone s_1.20_l_0.40_h_0.60 b_1.50_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.300 S_3.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
feather s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_1.20_l_0.05_h_0.30 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.300 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
beehive s_1.80_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_5.0_s_1.5_t_10.0 s_1.00_l_13.0_a_0.80
turtle s_0.60_l_0.50_h_0.90 b_0.60_l_0.15_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.300 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_1.00_l_8.0_a_0.90
tiger s_0.60_l_0.50_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_2.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
briefcase s_1.20_l_0.20_h_0.80 b_1.50_l_0.05_h_0.45 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.050 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
trashcan s_1.80_l_0.20_h_0.70 b_1.50_l_0.05_h_0.45 n_6_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_3.0_s_1.5_t_10.0 s_1.00_l_8.0_a_0.95
videocamera s_1.80_l_0.20_h_0.70 b_1.50_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.000 S_3.0_s_1.5_t_10.0 s_1.00_l_8.0_a_0.90
coffee maker s_1.20_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_1.50_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.050 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
flower s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.300 S_2.0_s_1.0_t_15.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
airplane s_0.60_l_0.50_h_0.90 b_1.50_l_0.20_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.550 S_4.0_s_1.5_t_20.0 s_1.00_l_18.0_a_0.80
traffic cone s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.90 b_1.20_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.000_h_0.300 S_2.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80
stairs s_0.60_l_0.30_h_0.80 b_1.20_l_0.10_h_0.60 n_8_l_0.200_h_0.550 S_2.0_s_2.0_t_20.0 s_0.50_l_18.0_a_0.80